Fluttershy is so sweet, kind and adorable. I really love submissive girls, they attract me so much, I just want to hold them and nuzzle them close, protect them and help them enjoy themselves. I have a huge crush on Flutters. None of the male ponies appeal to me, there are less of them after all and they're not main characters.
Spike, Pinkie Pie, or Caramel. Yes two different genders. Fight me about it xD Hmm... But... Out of them all, I'd PROBABLY go for Spike first. If you know, he wasn't straight. -Welcome to the world of Fanfictiiooonn where all your wildest dreams come true-