Ponyville Horror

DISCLAIMER: All rights reserved to any creators in association with My Little Pony© All characters from said animation are the property of the creators. If you don’t read about everypony dying then run along.

Ponyville Horror

The sun shone through the last bit of sky between the clouds the pegasi were putting about. There was a scheduled downpour, and ponies scattered about preparing. Pinkie Pie was gathering up baked goods that were sat out on display and bringing them inside. Twilight Sparkler trotted over to her.
“Hey, Pinkie, need some help?” Twilight asked. Pinkie sat down a basket of food.
“No thanks, Twilight. I’m almost done.” She replied cheerfully. She picked up the basket and put them inside. Twilight followed her into Sugarcube Corner.
“Well, im having another sleepover. You wanna come?” Twilight said as Pinkie turned to her.
“Oh, id love to Twilight, but I have some baking to do for the celebration tomorrow.” Pinkie blinked.
“That’s alright. Maybe some other time? Ive gotta go. Everypony else is waiting at the library. Ill see you tomorrow!” Twilight said.
“Okey dokey!” Pinkie closed the door behind Twilight after she galloped out. Pinkie walked into the kitchen and got out a mixing bowl and a cook book. She flipped the book open.
“Cupcakes! Yummy!” She said to herself as she began to shuffle about for ingredients. Quickly, she mixed up all the ingredients. She picked up the mixing bowl with her mouth to carry it over to pour it. A loud crack of thunder shook the building scaring Pinkie and causing her to scream. She dropped the pan and it spilt all over the floor.
“Oh stupid weather! Why did they schedule a downpour the day before the celebration. Its going to be so muddy tomorrow.” She grumbled. Pinkie trotted over to find something to clean up. Just as she passed by the door it burst open and a pony ran in, soaked and covered in mud. Pinkie jumped and turned around. The pony was so covered in mud and sticks she was unrecognizable.
“Oh no! Are you ok?” Pinkie went over to the pony.
“My, that was quite the gust of wind!” The other pony said in a similar high pitched voice to Pinkie’s.
“You look like you really need to clean up. Why don’t you come and take a bath?” Pinkie offered.
“Oh no, I couldn’t. I needn’t waste your time.” The pony blinked through mud.
“Its no problem at all!” Pinkie smiled, “I have a nice bath right upstairs.” She grabbed hold of the pony and dragged her upstairs. She left behind a thick trail of mud up the stairs. Pinkie let go of the pony and started the water, putting her face in the stream to wash the mud off herself.
“When this fills up just turn it off. I’ve gotta go clean up. Mr. and Mrs. Cake wouldn’t like a bunch of mud all over the place!” Pinkie trotted off. The pony twitched then stepped into the tub, trying not to slip. She rolled about trying to get the mud out of her mane. It revealed her to be all pink, a lot like Pinkie Pie. She gave a disgusted look at the water in the tub and began to drain it. Once it was drained she turned the water on again to get cleaner water. She slowly sunk herself into the warm water and sat for a minute with just her eyes and nose up out of the water. It was the first time in a while she could relax.
The pony jumped as Pinkie came in through the door. Pinkie Pie looked at her a little surprised as she walked over to the tub.
“You look a lot like me!” She exclaimed.
“I know! It’s interesting. Except my eyes are green, and I have a different cutie mark.” The pony blinked.
“So what’s your name? I’m Pinkie Pie!” Pinkie asked.
“Well that’s just not possible. My name is Shivie Pie!” Shivie said.
“Haha, its like were long lost sisters or something.” Pinkie giggled.
“I don’t have any siblings.” Shivie pondered.
“That’s why youre long lost. Duh” Pinkie made a face.
“Well, I guess ill get out of the bath. No more mud.” She smiled. Shivie stepped out of the tun carefully. Pinkie walked across the room.
“I have a blow dryer if youd like to use it.” Pinkie said.
“Oh, yes. My hair take the longest to air dry.” She walked up next to Pinkie. Pinkie pushed the button on the side of it and it turned on. Shivie sat under it letting in dry her hair. It dried quickly, yet the air from the dryer made it tangled.
“Hey! Can I brush your hair? It’s so long!” Pinkie jumped a bit.
“Sure, its always a bit of a hassle doing it myself.” Shivie replied. Pinkie went over and picked up a brush then began brushing Shivies hair. It was very long, and was straight until the end where it curled up a bit. Pinkie finished brushing her hair and put down the brush.
“Its so pretty, Shivie, how did you get it so long?” Pinkie asked.
“I never get too much of a chance to get it cut, but I like it long.” She replied.
“I bet my friend Rarity will just love your hair. She wont be able to keep her hooves off it.” Pinkie laughed. Shivie smiled.
“So what were you doing before I was blown through your door?” Shivie glanced at the bathroom door.
“I was trying to make cupcakes for the Summer Sun Celebration tomorrow, but thunder frightened me and I dropped the bowl. I was going to clean it up when you burst in the door.” Pinkie said.
“Well, I could help you make them. How hard can cupcakes be, right?” Shivie suggested.
“Good idea!” Pinkie agreed. She opened the door and galloped down the stairs. Shivie followed. Pinkie had already cleaned up the mess on the stairs and in the kitchen. She grabbed a clean bowl out of a cabinet and laid it on the table. She and Shivie poked about the kitchen gathering ingredients. Pinkie looked at Shivie.
“You seem to know a lot about making cupcakes!” Pinkie smiled.
“Oh yes. I love cooking. I usually do a lot of cutting up ingredients, hence my cutie mark being a knife. Its kind of misleading to other ponies. A little scary looking.” Shivie laughed. Pinkie laughed also.
“I got my cutie mark from parties. I love parties!” Pinkie smiled.
“We sure do have a lot in common!” Shivie laughed.
“Yeah! Maybe after the celebration we can go see my parents. Maybe they know something.” Pinkie said sarcastically and laughed. She poured the batter into the pan without spilling this time and put them into the oven.
“So whats this Summer Sun Celebration?” Shivie asked.
“Well, once a year, on the longest day of the year, ponies from all around gather in a determined area to watch Princess Celestia make the sun rise. It was supposed to be in Ponyville last year, but there was a bit of a, um, mishap. So were doing it here again to make up for that.” Pinkie explained. Shivie nodded.
Pinkie looked outside. It was beginning to get dark. It had also stopped raining.
“That’s strange”, She said as she walked over to the window, “It was supposed to rain all night.” Pinkie blinked. Shivie walked over to her.
“Maybe they stopped it early so it wasn’t really muddy tomorrow?” She looked out the window also.
“I guess so! Who needs gloomy rain anyways?” Pinkie made a gesture. Shivie smiled and shrugged. Pinkie trotted delightfully to the oven and checked on the cupcakes.
“Done!” Pinkie said happily.
“My, that was fast.” Shivie looked at the cupcakes as Pinkie took them out of the oven. She sat them down.
“You have to have a fast oven when you work in a bakery!” Pinkie told her.
“That makes sense.” Shivie said, then yawned.
“Oh, are you tired? You can sleep here if you want. Where do you live anyways?” Pinkie walked over to her.
“A little. And im sort of a traveler. I usually end up staying in strangers homes.” She smiled.
“Theyre not strangers really, you seem like you get to know them before you sleep in their house.” Pinkie smiled back.
“Well yeah, I don’t just sort of waltz in and sleep on their couch without saying anything.” Shivie laughed.
“Why would you be waltzing? No pony waltzes into a house, silly.” Pinkie said. Shivie sort of rolled her eyes.
“I guess ill be sleeping on your couch?” Shivie asked.
“Um I guess. I don’t have any extra beds.” Pinkie looked about as if looking for one.
“Sleeping in the same bed as you would be a bit awkward.” She and Pinkie laughed. Pinkie trotted into a sort of living room area and got a blanket and pillow out of a nearby closet. She threw them onto the couch.
“There ya go!” Pinkie smiled at her and went back to the kitchen. Shivie thanked her as she left and walked over to the couch. She nuzzled the covers back and got under them. Soon, she fell asleep.

~

Shivie woke up to Pinkie Pie in her face.
“Good Morning!” Pinkie Pie said quite loudly. Shivie could hear the bustle of other people conversing in the other room. She looked around to notice she was in a different room than she had fallen asleep in.
“Did you move the couch, with me on it?” Shivie asked, noticing she was in the kitchen.
“Yup! It was no problem. I had to move some of the furniture so it wasn’t in the way.
“Wait…did I miss the sun rise?” Shivie jumped up and looked out the window. It was still dark.
“Nope! Its really early, but its gonna be soon. I came in here to wake you up but you woke up just as I was about to.” Pinkie Pie smiled.
“Oh good. I wouldn’t want to have missed it.” Shivie laughed.
“You should come meet all of my friends!” Pinkie grabbed her and drug her into the other room. She brought Shivie through the crowd of people to where the other girls were. Pinkie stopped in from of them.
“Shivie, this is Twilight Sparkle, Rainbow Dash, Rarity, Fluttershy, and Applejack. Everypony, this is Shivie.” Pinkie introduced them. They all greeted her.
“So where ya from?” Applejack asked.
“No where special.” Shivie laughed.
“Anypony’s true home is special.” Fluttershy said. Shivie sort of fake smiled.
“You and Pinkie sure look a lot alike, are you sisters or something?” Rainbow asked.
“We’re not quite sure about that.” Shivie laughed.
“Why don’t you go ask Pinkie’s parents?” Twilight suggested. Rarity was admiring Shivie’s hair. Shivie gave her a strange look.
“Oh excuse me, your hair is gorgeous. How do you keep it so silky?” Rarity asked. The other ponies rolled their eyes.
“Uh, well I travel a lot so I don’t really know how it stays so nice.” Shivie sort of sidestepped away from Rarity.
A pony shouted from across the room.
“Its time for the princess to rise the sun!” Ponies began to crowd out the door. The girls followed everypony to an even bigger crowd where an elaborate stage was set up for when the princess rose the sun. Ponies began to quiet down when the mayor walked upon the stage to the mic. She cleared her throat.
“Fillies and Gentlecoalts, welcome to this years Summer Sun Celebration!” She said and paused for cheering, “It is my pleasure to introduce Princess Celestia to come and make the sun rise!” More cheering enveloped the area. The mayor bowed her head and walked back off the stage as Princess Celestia came upon the stage. The large crowd of ponies bowed to her in unison.
Without speaking, the princess’s horn began to light up with powerful magic. She began to levitate into the air, and with the flap of her wings once, she spread out her body in an upright position and the sun slowly rose over the horizon. All of the ponies began stomping their hooves in applause at the sight. The princess lowered herself back down and gave a bow and thanked everypony. She walked gracefully off the stage and the crowd began to break up; ponies going to various after parties walked off. The group of girls walked over to the princess. Twilight trotted to her.
“Celestia!” She greeted her.
“Twilight! My student.” Celestias luminous voice filled the air.
“What have you been up to lately?” Twilight asked her.
“Oh, you know, normal ruler stuff.” She laughed, “But, ive met all your friends, so who is this new face?” Celestia pointed towards Shivie.
“Oh this is Shivie,” Twilight said, Celestia twitched a bit at the name,” shes sort of a traveler.”
“Its nice to meet you.” The princess said.
“You too, your highness.” Shivie bowed timidly. A royal guard came up to the princess and whispered something in her ear. Her face darkened a bit.
“Well it seems I must be off. Theres just so much business I have to tend to. Im so sorry I couldn’t stay. Ill come visit you all soon.” Celestia said.
“Oh already?” Twilight asked.
“Id stay if I could. Ill see you again soon. Goodbye.” She hopped into her carriage and they flew off.
“where do you think she had to go so fast?” Pinkie asked.
“I don’t know. Usually she doesn’t have anything to tend to on the celebrations.” Twilight said with a confused look about her face. Pinkie turned to Shivie.
“Well, wanna go see my parents now?” She asked.
“Sure!” Shivie smiled.
“Were gonna go visit my parents. You guys stay here and have fund. We’ll be back soo!” Pinkie said as she and Shivie trotted off.

~

Pinkie and Shivie arrived at Pinkies parents house.
“Oh, you’re going to love my parents. They lightened up a bit about light when I showed them a bit of happiness.” Pinkie said knocking on the door. Pinkies mom cake to the door.
“Hello?” she looked up.
“Mommy!” Pinkie said loudly. Pinkies mom was staring at Shivie with her eyes wide.
“Y-y-…” She stuttered.
“Mommy?” Pinkie glanced at Shivie who was just as confused as she was. Pinkies mom slowly backed away into the house.
“What is it?” Pinkie followed her inside. Pinkies dad turned to see Shivie walk into the house after Pinkie. His face became as terrified as Pinkies moms.
“Why are you here?” He asked Shivie. Shivie looked at him confused then looked around the house a bit. She twitched.
“Shivie, are you ok?” Pinkie turned to her. Strange memories flashed before Shivie’s eyes. Flashes of blood dripped walls and ominous laughter. It was like her past was catching up to her. Her pupils dilated and she blinked. She stared at Pinkie for a bit.
“I…I don’t know.” Shivie looked at Pinkies parents who were terrified.
“Mom, Dad, are you ok?” Pinkie walked over to them.
“Get her…out of our house, Pinkie.” Her mom said, startled.
“Why?” Pinkie glanced at her.
“Shes…shes your sister.” Her dad said. A smile grew on Pinkies face. Shivie stood there stunned.
“This is nothing to smile about Pinkamena. She…shes a murderer!” Pinkies mom burst out in tears. Pinkies smile faded.
“What?” She said quietly. Shivie blinked.
“She killed your grandparents! And some dear friends of ours. She almost killed us too! Don’t you see, we dont want her here?!” Pinkies dad threw his arm up in the air. Pinkie turned around to see Shivie was enraged.
“How can you say this? I don’t remember anything like this at all!” She yelled.
“Is this true, Shivie? Did you repress memories of this?” Pinkies eyes watered. Shivie rubbed her eyes and shook her head.
“I…I don’t know!” the memories continued to flash and one of her blood soaked face began to haunt her, “I don’t…i…” she stopped. Her eyes grew vacant. She blinked. She slowly trotted into the kitchen. The other three awaited her in the living room, horrified. Shivie walked back in with a knife. Pinkies mom screamed and fainted.
“Run, Pinkie!” Her dad yelled. Pinkie stood frozen with fear, crying. Shivie flung the knife at her father and it pierced him in the head. Pinkie burst out crying. Shivies hysterical laughter filled the house. She walked over her mother, whom was still passed out, and began to bash her head in with her hooves. Pinkie screamed more.
“NO!” Pinkie screamed, tears streamed down her face, “No, no, no!” She continued to cry. Shivie walked over and ripped the knife out of her fathers head, and approached Pinkie with it. Pinkie swallowed hard and turned and ran out of the house. Shivie ran after her.

~

Twilight laughed as Rainbow did a funny trick. The girls turned their attention when they heard screaming approaching them. They saw Pinkie Pie running as fast as she could towards them. A pegasi flew down next to Rainbow and whispered to her. Rainbow shoed the pegasi as Pinkie slid to a stop in front of them. Her face was soaked in tears.
“Whats wrong Pinkie?” Twilight asked concerned.
“Shivie! Murder! Parents!” She said through sobs. She turned to see Shivie running fast to them. Pinkie’s eyes grew wide and she began running again. The girls looked confused and watched as Shivie ran at them. Applejack stood in front of the group.
“Hold on there, missy!” Applejack said when Shivie came up to them, covered in blood and holding a knife, “What do you think youre doing chasing Pinkie like this?” She looked her up and down. Shivie flipped her hair a bit and jumped at Applejack, slitting her throat deep. Applejack stumbled about, trying to hold her neck. The other girls screamed and ran crying. Shivie ran after and followed them to the center of Ponyville where everypony was out socializing. Shivie ran at Twilight, but was beginning to lose her in the crowd. Bystanders watched the scene, confused. Shivie slashed a pony who was standing in her way, and the crowd began to scatter and scream in horror.
Shivie began brutally killing the closest thing to her. Soon the town became a blood bath. Pinkie Pie and the other girls ran into Sugarcube Corner. Rainbow locked the door.
“Applejack! She…killed…” Fluttershy sobbed. The other girls cried along with her.
“Pinkie…who is she?” Twilight sniffled.
“Shes…my sister.” Pinkie said as the girls let out a gasp. Thunder and lightning could be heard outside.
“Whats this?” Rarity exclaimed.
“The rest of that downpour…” Rainbow said wiping a tear off. They could hear screaming outside, some cut off, others died as they got further away. The girls huddled in the corner until there wasn’t screaming anymore.
“Do you think….everypony is dead? Rarity whispered.
“Don’t say that.” Twilight whispered back. A lone distant scream came from outside.
“How about now?” Rarity shivered. The door slammed open, and lighting flashed showing Shivie, almost completely covered in blood. The girls screamed and got up. They ran as fast they could through the building trying to hide. Shivie chased after Twilight once again. Twilight could hardly see through her tears. She quickly turned a corner and hid in a closet. Shivie laughed to herself a bit.
Rarity heard Twilights scream and winced. The scream cut off and Rarity burst out crying again. Fluttershy, also crying covered Rarity’s mouth to keep her quiet, but Shivie already found them in the pantry. Fluttershy jumped and ran out of there. Shivie ignored her and came at Rarity. Rarity screamed.
“No! Please No!” She cowered as Shivie brought her knife down on her. Rarity screamed as she was being stabbed continuously until she died. Rainbow Dash lay covering her own mouth, while she listened to the horrific sounds. The house went silent. Then Shivie flipped the bed that Rainbow was hiding under. Rainbow looked up at her terrified.
“N-“ her scream was cut in half as Shivie slashed at her repeatedly. Fluttershy had found Pinkie and they sat crying silently holding each other.
“Fluttershy?” Pinkie whispered.
“Y-yeah?” Fluttershy opened her eyes.
“Were gonna have to…” Pinkie gave her a look. Fluttershy nodded then shivered a bit.
“You know whats funny, Pinkie?” She whispered.
“What?” Pinkie blinked.
“Everyponies dead.” Fluttershy smiled.
“Yeah.” Pinkie began to giggle. She and Fluttershy both began to laugh. It grew into an uproar of malevolent laughter. Shivie heard it and it led her to the basement where Pinkie and Fluttershy laughed. She barged in, hot with rage that they were laughing. The two girls pointed at Shivie and laughed manically.
“Stop laughing at me, you insolent little swine!” Shivie yelled at them. They only laughed harder. Shivie brought the knife over to Fluttershy. Their laughing stopped and they both became serious as she put the knife to Fluttershy’s throat. Fluttershy stared deep into Shivies eyes. Shivie began to feel more vulnerable. Less powerful. She felt scared. She dropped the knife and backed away. Pinkie picked up the knife, and she and Fluttershy slowly approached Shivie as she backed away. Shivie was back up against the wall upright. Pinkie stabbed the knife through Shivies arm and pinned it to the wall.
Shivie screamed in pain. She wanted to reach over and pull the knife out but Pinkie and Fluttershy turned and began bucking her very hard in the stomach. Shivie screamed and coughed.
“Stop! Please! Im sorry.” She screamed. Close to Shivies death, the two stopped bucking her. They stood back and began laughing at her again. Shivie coughed and puked up blood, hanging there on the wall. Shivie looked up at the laughing girls. They both stopped laughing and gave her an angry look. Pinkie Pie turned around and bucked Shivie hard in the face, killing her.