Well I went to AC (Anthrocon) back in June which is the biggest furry convention of the year if you didn't know. I went because 1.) I live in Pittsburgh, so I just have to hop a bus down to town, and 2.) My friend was going, and her friend couldn't go so she wanted some one to go with. While I was there, I figured I might as well grab some pony stuff o_o. I got some Fluttershy hats\buttons\badges, even though I wanted a Twilight Sparkle hat, I couldn't find any one selling them so I just decided to deck out in Fluttershy, since it suits my personality better. (Never took a pic of the hat). Excuse the poor quality, thanks to my webcam, and the random hand holding the paraphernalia o_o.
I have a hunch you like Fluttershy? I just have 1 Rainbow Dash button. I don't know why they always get the cutie mark wrong though.